Printer inks and tractors, and the right to repair

You might recall several years ago when it came time to replace an “empty” Lexmark printer cartridge, you had to purchase a new “authentic” one as a replacement. HP had a similar program. Lexmark was sued (and lost in the Supreme Court) by a third-party ink maker who was blocked by the locking software. (The reason for the quotes is because these cartridges are seldom anywhere near empty, wasting a lot of ink. But let’s stay focused.)

John Deere 8 Series Tractor MY22 updates give farmers more optionsWhat does this have in common with tractors? John Deere has special locking software that prevents farmers from doing their own repairs. This came to light recently when Russian troops stole about US$5M worth of them from Ukraine and brought them to Chechnya. The Ukrainians were able to “brick” the tractors by engaging the software. This is not a coincidence: their software engineers have been hacking Deere tractors for years.

Now, while you may cheer on the Ukrainians, this exposes the dark side of tech called the right to repair. For the past decade, tech companies have come under fire for preventing “unauthorized” repair work on their equipment. Apple is one of the most egregious, you can’t just have anyone fix your gear. But as supply chains stretch and break during the pandemic, we need more flexibility, not less. And typically using the authorized repair folks is nothing more than having an added surcharge to your repair bill. (And if you are a farmer, waiting for the Deere repair dude to drive out to your farm.)

One small victory in this arena has been the unlocking of cellphones. Remember when you had to get permission from your phone vendor if you wanted to port your phone and your number to another carrier? You still need to go through a somewhat dense process, but at least the carriers have to sell you a new unlocked phone. Various states now have laws on their books to mandate rights to repair, but it still is far from universal.

3 thoughts on “Printer inks and tractors, and the right to repair

  1. My father and now my nephews are farmers and the average American has no idea how hard of a life this can be. You are very dependent on something you cannot control, the weather. To be really good as a farmer you also have to become a part time stock broker to understand when to buy and sell your crops and you often have to choose whether to take a low price or pay someone to store your grain with a hope prices will get good enough for you to make a little more after you paid the person to store it. There’s a reason the small farms have dried up as we’ve made it impossible for them to afford to be a farmer. To top this off by not letting them get their equipment fixed as they see fit for what these things cost is criminal! And as David hit it, you are waiting on their mechanic when you have a small window to plant or harvest and this could potentially kill your entire year. Free enterprise is not free enterprise when we do not give people the right to repair their own equipment. Talk about telling mother nature to stick it when you’d rather people throw things away than fix what they have.

  2. I’ve been following Louis Rossman in NYC on Youtube on this issue for years, where he’s testified and lobbied on the right to repair for a long time. He owns a repair shop in NYC.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.