Haters gonna hate: fighting Holocaust deniers across social media

A new report from the Anti-Defamation League has reviewed the stated hate speech policies of nine different social media platforms. Unlike other studies, it also tests their responsiveness to user reports of violations of those policies. The ADL is an organization that has been operating for more than 100 years trolling (literally) these waters. They were specifically interested in how social media propagated posts made by Holocaust deniers across their networks. They scored each platform in terms of intentions and how they performed in terms of preventing hate speech on such issues such as:

  • Did the platform investigate the report and promptly respond (defined as within 24 hours) to the complaint?
  • Do users of each platform understand why it has made a certain content decision based on its stated policies?
  • Did the platform take any actual action once something was reported?

You can see a part of their report card above. Before I get to the grades given for answering these and other questions, I want to talk about my own personal experience with Holocaust denial. About four years ago, my sister and I went to Poland to see the places where our mom’s family came from. One of our cousins did some genealogy research and found an ancestor who lived in a small town in northeast Poland who was a rabbinical judge back in the 1870s. One of the stops on our trip was to visit Auschwitz, and you can read my thoughts about that day here.

One of the exhibits at the site was about the German engineering firm that designed the mass extermination equipment. For years, the copies of the original drawings used to build this gear were kept from public view by the denier network. But eventually they were sold to someone who flipped from being a denier to someone who realized the legitimacy of these plans, and that’s how we were able to finally see them.

Several years ago I attended a lecture by Jan Grabowski, a history professor from Ottawa. He has done extensive research into Polish Holocaust history, despite the current denier political climate where he and his research associates and colleagues have been threatened and in some cases jailed for their work. Grabowski is affiliated with the Polish Center for Holocaust Research in Warsaw which is attempting to find primary source records to document what happened during those dark times. Add to this a recent survey of millennials that found that 56% of the respondents could not even identify what Auschwitz was about.

From these two personal moments, I realize that we need more evidence-based approaches and to disseminate facts rather than fiction or misdirection. That is where the social networks come into play, because they have become the superhighway of these fictions. Let’s not even glorify them by using the term “alternative facts.”

Let’s return to the report card. Sadly, only Twitter and Twitch acted against the Holocaust denial content reported. No network got any A grades across the ADL’s rubric, to no surprise. Twitch, the gaming social network, scored B’s. Twitter and You Tube got C’s. Facebook and others received grades of D.

Based on its research, the ADL has some recommendations:

  • Tech companies must make changes to their products to prioritize users’ safety over engagement and reduce hateful content on their platforms.
  • All the platforms need to do a better job on transparency. They should provide users with more information on how they make their decisions regarding content moderation. This is especially urgent, given the recent decisions to terminate several high-profile accounts.

You can read others at the link above. My final point: yes, censoring hate speech — whether it about the Holocaust or whatever — is destructive to our society. Just look at the mob that swarmed across our Capitol earlier this month. The social networks have to decide whether they can step up to the task. And while it bothers me that we have to censor the most dangerous of hate speakers, we do have to recognize their danger.

8 thoughts on “Haters gonna hate: fighting Holocaust deniers across social media

  1. David, My wife and I encountered Holocaust denial way before social media. When we lived in Europe, we became friends with a neighboring couple, the husband Italian and the wife German. Fast forward a few years when we had come back to the US, and each of the daughters summered with us, one bringing a German friend who stayed with friends of ours. The daughters of our Italo-German friends knew well about the Holocaust, being properly educated by their parents or their schooling. But the German friend vehemently denied the Holocaust and then became bewildered when shown photos of what went on in the death camps. Maybe we got through to her, maybe not. Holocaust denial is one of the many lies embraced by people following a false prophet or living in a totalitarian society.

  2. David – did you mean “yes, censoring hate speech — whether it about the Holocaust or whatever — is destructive to our society.” ? Censoring Hate speech – “destructinve? — Cynde

  3. Pingback: Telegram designs the ideal hate platform | Web Informant

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.